EXCELLENT pizza! I enjoyed my visit especially because i'm from up north.. Can definitely appreciate their pizza :-)... The crust wasn't too thick and not at all thin just right... I'd definitely refer this place to any and everyone! Not to mention the employees were very nice... Enjoy :-)

5 Stars - Absolutely the closest thing to real NYC Pizza...absolutely fabulous . The Lasagna is my personal favorite....coming from a displaced Manhattanite this is truly NY Pizza.... "forget about it!" Too bad they don't deliver

Unbelievable Pizza! I love green olives and ham pizza and couldn't find any pizza joint to make it. Found this one and it reminds me of home! This place is in speed dial on my phone.

Like so many of your customers, I came to FL from New York. Brooklyn to be exact. Throughout the year I have to travel back to NY for various reasons. The first thing I do when I get back is to come here and get a great slab or 2 of square Sicillian. As for the staff, I think they are all great and friendly. Although I think they are getting to know me by now. Keep it up everyone and Happy New Year.

Can't belive we found NY Pizza! My family and I moved to Tampa about 2 years ago and we could never find good pizza. We've tried all those "NY Style" Pizza places but none really tasted like NY. We finally stumbled upon this place and we have not looked back since!

Liked: Food, Service, Atmosphere

I'm sitting here actually connected on their new WIFI eating the most incredible pizza ever!!! Love the fact that I can sit here and enjoy this amazing slice of cheese pizza and stay connected with facebook! This deserved an instant review! I'll be eating lunch here more often!

Wow, what a difference! We normally come in during lunch throughout the week so imagine my surprise when we came in for dinner and find these two doors open leading into a new room that offers full service dining! At first we were a little leary about what their full service dining included (we thought it would be more expensive) I have to say that we were happily surprised to find that it's the same price regardless if we ate on the regular side or this side. The only difference that we found besides having a server was that they have what they call "New & Exclusive" items that you can only get on the full service side. We will be back and I think we will pick Mondays since that seems to be a quite night! See you soon!

I can't say enough great things about Best New York Pizza!!! I'm from Chicago, and have had my share of excellent pizza, .......I stopped in on a whim and have not had to look any further since. I recommend Best New York to anyone who is looking for authentic pizza made with fresh ingredients and served by an incredibly curteous staff! You HAVE to try Best New York...I promise you will NOT be disappointed!